Recently I've been thinking about nationality and what it
means for me to be American. See,
there's no possible way you can walk around here without being asked the
inevitable question, where are you from?
And while most people from the U.S. will have it pretty easy (unless you
speak with an accent, if you are white people will assume you are from the
states) because of my ambiguous looks I am constantly getting this question.
When I
answer, I'm from the U.S. , they look at me like they aren't quite sure what
that means. I've thrown them for a loop;
what with my dark hair, my dark eyes, and brown skin I am anything but the
poster child of America, despite the fact that "minorities" (i.e.
brown people) more than make up the majority.
It doesn't help that I tell them I'm teaching Japanese at a woman's
college but it does give them a starting point for their next question.
"Are
your parents from Japan?"
No siree
bob, there is not a single drop of Japanese blood in my veins. Or Chinese, or Thai, or Nepalese, or Tibetan,
or Arabic. Those are just a few of the
many guesses that tend to pop up. In
fact one (drunk) Arabic guy kept following me around slurring, "But you
are the most beautiful Arabic woman I have ever seen!" Somehow my repeated protests of 'I'm MEXICAN'
didn't make it past the beer haze. But
then I suppose that's my fault for trying to correct a drunk.
The
point is people tend to guess everything under the sun except for what I am,
Mexican-American. And what does that
even mean? Do I hold two
nationalities? Nope. Am I more Mexican than American? Well if I
went down to Mexico I'm sure they would make fun of me for my funny spanish. Yet here in the U.S. it's naturally assumed
my parents are immigrants and thus I only have my birth to prove my true
"heritage" (despite the fact that Mexicans have been in the Americas
for far longer than our European-bred American citizens, we are still being
told to go home. Ahem, we ARE home,
that's the joke). Abroad this idea is
even more implicit which is why I can never simply say I'm American.
No Jazmin, where are you REALLY from?
Where am I really from?
Well to be perfectly honest I have no idea. I think the movie Selena put it best (sorry
but I'm taking it there).
"We
have to be more Mexican than the Mexicans, and American than the Americans,
because our home is right next door."
This has
always resonated with me. I know that it's
not like there are people running around constantly telling us to prove our
culture but I couldn't help feeling like I was never good enough for either
group. This is made even worse when I
run into non-native Spanish speakers whose Spanish is more grammatically
correct than mine and never fail to spell a word in Spanish correctly. I can't help but feel an immediate dislike
and anger towards them that I know is completely irrational. I want to scream at them, pull their hair, spit
at them and protect my country because as hard as they study they'll never have
the ancestry that exists in the blood beneath my skin. For some reason I feel I have to protect that
heritage, yet I know I'm being a hypocrite.
Here I am teaching Japanese despite the fact that I'm not Japanese
myself. Just like those non-native
Spanish speakers will never know what it's like to wake up to your parents
blasting Vicente Fernandez in the early morning with the smell of burning
chiles itching your throat, I will never know what it's like to be Japanese and
all that goes with it.
I
realize this all goes back to issues dealing with my heritage and what it means
to be a Mexican-American; I still remember coming home from school telling my
parents I didn't want to speak Spanish anymore because all the kids in class
kept making fun of my brother and me. I
regret that moment more than any other in my life and I don't know who to hate
more. Those kids who laughed at us when
we answered questions in Spanish or myself for letting it get to me.
Another
part of this probably has to do with my difficulties in interacting with my
abuelitos. My abuelo who speaks both
English and Spanish I never had a problem with, but with my abuela who only speaks
Spanish I always felt like I was missing out on a closer relationship. I wanted so badly to be able to communicate
with her yet whenever my family and I spent time in Vegas I immediately became
tongue-tied and nervous. It was like I
was being cross-examined by my own family and if I failed it meant I should be
kicked out, although this was an absolute falsity only existing in my mind.
You
might be wondering why on earth I'm discussing this on a blog meant to be about
India. But it is in fact India that has
re-awoken this turmoil inside of me. Every
time someone asks that dreaded question, "Where are you REALLY from?"
I revert back to that angry child who wants to claw someone's eyes out. The simple answer is, I don't know. For the past 4 years I've been spending at
least 2 of them abroad and the more I think about it the more I realize I might
not find myself gravitating back to the U.S. anytime soon. Do I really belong there even though so many
of my fellow citizens would be more than happy to see me gone?
Do I
belong to Mexico, a country that I've not spent more than a few weeks at a time
in? In government-terms that would be a
definite no. Even culturally, how could
I say that Mexico is my native place despite never having had the chance to
experience life there? I am simply
floating in a limbo of nationalities. My
passport say's American but my skin say's otherwise. Perhaps this is what
globalization does to us in the end, simply scatters us to the point where we
can't recognize ourselves any longer.
The
other reason I've become so introspective is because if I'm not truly a
Mexicana than that means I'm simply American and that terrifies me more than
anything else in the world. In India
they are constantly telling me there is a reason for everything they do. There is a reason for the bindi, it cools the
forehead (and in a place like Madurai you can bet every little thing helps);
there's a reason they wear their anklets and a reason why they wear gold. They don't just do these things because it's
the cool thing to do but because their history has taught them. They know how to utilize the heat to their
advantage and what the best meals are to cook and so on and so forth. America simply doesn't have that; partially
because we are too young but also because we are so incredibly diverse there's
no way we can decide on one heritage.
That's why we hyphenate everything, Mexican-American, Indian-American,
Italian-American, we need some kind of identifier so we know how to categorize
people.
But you
see I want that lineage. I need those ancestors and all the
collective knowledge they've gained because without it I'm nothing but a
blip. I need something to teach to those
who come after me and a firm identity in which to stamp them with. And if I don't belong to Mexico and I don't
belong to the U.S. then where do I belong?
Perhaps
this is why I am constantly on the move, always wanting to see as many new
cities as possible. I'm subconsciously
searching for the place I feel a connection with and now I understand that's
how I've viewed languages. I've never
wanted to learn languages that I have no interest in. For example people kept telling me to learn
Chinese but I had no desire to do so despite how beneficial it might have
been. I wanted to learn Japanese because
for some reason or another something about it resonated with me. The sound was familiar and comforting. Maybe I'm waiting for someone to ground me to
one country, I'm not sure. I suppose
I'll just have to keep searching and hope that someday that search takes me
back home a mi gente.
That's such a coincidence, I talked about the same question in my blog post yesterday (Although I'm not even in India yet, but I anticipate the question anyway, and am trying to devise a way to respond...). It is kind of terrifying for our generation of neither-this-nor-thats to understand who we are...but I dunno...I also find it kind of liberating. Of course it's frustrating as hell to explain to other people "what" it is we are - my birth place, where I grew up, the languages I now speak--none of it lines up in a way that makes much sense - but in the end we are all shaped and carved by our life experiences anyway and what we choose to make of it. And realizing that gives others less of a standard template to judge you by, and I feel like it requires others to get to know me better as an individual. What do you feel like you've really connected with in Madurai? What have you picked up in the past year that you'll keep with you once this fellowship is over? :)
ReplyDeleteThis definitely resonates with me. Saying that my mum is from Malaysia makes so much sense to everyone here, but among other things neglects the whole Chinese aspect of my heritage entirely. Identity is cooomplicated.
ReplyDeleteIt's nice to hear that other people feel the same way. I know what you mean about things making sense to people Zoe, as soon as I tell people my parents are from Mexico there's this collective, "Ohhhh, I see." It's kind of funny but also sort of like, ok how many times are we going to go through this. Btw why do they ignore the fact that you have Chinese heritage?
ReplyDeleteThere's definitely a lot I'm going to take with me after this fellowship is over. Part of it is this realization that there's very few things I can't do (not to sound completely full of myself), in the sense that if I can survive living by myself in India without any previous knowledge than I'm pretty sure I can survive anywhere else. Also a sense of strength I think.
Unfortunately I've also made some other nasty realizations I'm not happy about, such as the reality that simply because I'm a woman there are a lot of things I'm not going to be able to do or have to think twice about. I never wanted to accept that until after India. I'm actually curious Zoe to hear if you ever got that in Indonesia. For instance despite how many times I want to stop by the tea stalls by the side of the road it's not something I do because I'm alone and the patrons are solely comprised of men.
As for connections there are a bunch. I've definitely gotten close to the people who work at the college and it's sometimes as simple as chatting with the patti who sells fruit outside the college walls. Also I don't know why but I feel like I'm reconnecting with different aspects of my childhood here. That's probably the next mystery I'll try to figure out.
Re: The Chinese thing
ReplyDeleteIt's not that they ignore it, but trying to get into the "Well, actually, my mum's Chinese but she's from Malaysia" makes everything really complicated. One country people can deal with. Adding in the complexities of immigration ends up confusing people all over again.
Re: Being a woman
You should ask Sara about this one. She has a lot to say. I'm lucky that I'm living in a city where I'm pretty free to do whatever I want. Being a woman alone, even at night, can maybe be a little bit weird but isn't unheard of at all. I live with a guy and I have no problems with the neighbors. (Granted, it was hard to find a neighborhood where this was okay, but it's possible.)
I do, though, get what you say about little roadside stands. There are those things here too, and I'm still terrified to go to them by myself because they are usually just filled with men. (I could still do it, but sometimes (read: always) I don't want to deal with all the questions and unwanted attention.) I wouldn't hesitate to go with another girl, though. And I did have a really good experience when Amy was here. I took her to one in the late afternoon and, to my surprise, there were only women.
tl;dr: Life isn't as restrictive here as I thought it would be, but I get what you mean.
hello jazmin
ReplyDeletei need a professional who teach me spanish
you can help me??